Friday, February 8, 2013

My Sister Lives on the Mantelpiece Review

My Sister Lives on the Mantelpiece is a short novel about ten year old Jamie and his family. His older sister Jasmine is fifteen. She had a twin named Rose that died five years earlier in a traumatic explosion. Muslims had hidden several bombs in garbage cans around London and Rose just happened to be near one when the bombs were planned to go off. Her body, and her family were torn apart in the aftermath.  

Now, five years later, Jamie can't understand why his mother has left his family for a man she met in a support group. He also can't comprehend why his dad drinks all the time and sets food next to his sister's golden urn on the mantelpiece.

His dad decides to relocate so they move away from London and their mother. His father still drinks and he hardly hears from his mother. Soon Jamie is faced with a terrifying decision. Ever since Rose was blown up his father has had a burning hatred for Muslims. Whenever they are around he screams that Muslims killed his daughter and that they should go back to their country. Jamie doesn't carry any of his father's hatred because he was so young when Rose died that he doesn't even remember her or feel sad about her death. At his new school the only person who pays him any positive attention is a girl named Sunya who is of Muslim faith. 

Throughout the course of the novel Jamie struggles with liking Sunya and trying to keep their friendship from his father. He goes through periods of time where he second guesses his friendship with Sunya and treats her as badly as the other kids in their class. He is confused about whether to accept her or stay loyal to his father. His sister has similar burdens since she remembers Rose and is constantly having to live up to her parents' depiction of her sister because they were twins. She completely changes her appearance in an attempt to shed Rose from her life.

My Sister Lives on the Mantelpiece raises many questions about discrimination. While Jamie's father justified his hatred of Muslims, he never really took the time to think that not all of them were terrorists. He harbored the opinion that all Muslim men sat home every day constructing bombs in their bedrooms. This book also raises questions of abandonment since Jamie and Jasmine's parents both checked out on their parenting duties when Rose died.  

This novel is a powerful story and has helped me in my own writing because of its intensity and clarity. It raises important issues and at the end it all comes together when Jamie finally understands why his father is still so upset by Rose's death. His father also understands that he has neglected Jamie and Jas and has to let go of Rose because his living in the past has only harmed his family. 

1 comment:

  1. Nice job relating a novel you are reading with your own work. Well done. This looks like a great book and I will add it to my list.

    ReplyDelete